Answer #65
Three possible hands are given for South but only one is consistent with bidding. Which one? What should the other hands have bid? Neither side is vulnerable
North |
|
East |
|
South |
|
West |
--
Rdbl |
|
--
2 ♣ |
|
1♠
2♦ |
|
Dbl |
Hand a) |
♠ 9 6 4 3 2
♥ K Q
♦ Q 8 4 3 2
♣ K |
|
Hand b) |
♠ A Q 7 6 2
♥ 8 5 2
♦ A K 7 2
♣ 2 |
|
Hand c) |
♠ K J 9 7 2
♥ J 3
♦ K Q 8 3 2
♣ 8 |
Answer:
(c) is correct.
-
Partner’s redouble shows a hand of about ten or more points and typically no great spade fit. It creates an “auction force”, meaning your partnership cannot let the opponents play (undoubled); your partnership must either bid on or double them. This means your pass over 2 ♣ would be forcing – partner could not pass; this means you do not have to bid. If you do bid (in front of partner, who may be wishing to double the opponents for penalties), you are showing a shapely, minimum opener, unsuited to defence:
-
Hand (c) is perfect.
-
Hand (b) is good defensively, so you should pass over 2 ♣. If partner doubles, you should pass again – and lead your singleton trump.
-
Hand (a) is so yucky, with all those points in the short suits, that you should not open the bidding at all (although it satisfies the Rule of 20 – or should I say Guideline of 20).
please click here to return to questions