Answer #68
Three possible hands are given for South but only one is consistent with the bidding. Which one? What should the other hands have bid? Neither side is vulnerable
North |
|
East |
|
South |
|
West |
--
1NT
2 ♠ |
|
--
P
P |
|
1 ♠
2♥
3 ♠ |
|
P
P |
Hand a) |
♠ A Q 9 8 3 2
♥ A J 9 2
♦ A 3
♣ 3 |
|
Hand b) |
♠ A K 9 3 2
♥ A Q 8 2
♦ J 6
♣ K 2 |
|
Hand c) |
♠ A J 9 4 3
♥ K J 5 3
♦ Q J 2
♣ K |
Answer:
(a) is correct.
-
Partner has responded the “dustbin 1NT” and given you preference back to 2♠, your five-card suit. She has a poor hand and her most likely number of spades is two. Therefore, you need a good hand (in shape and/or strength) to proceed; and to bid 3♠, guaranteeing a fit, you need six spades.
-
Hand (a) is perfect.
-
With Hand (b), too much strength to pass 2♠, you should move with 2NT, implying this shape and strength.
-
With Hand (c), however, a poorish 15-count including a singleton king, facing partner’s 6-9 points, you should pass 2♠.