Whilst suit quality is the most important factor in deciding whether or not to overcall, strength of the overall hand cannot be ignored. The high-card requirements should be approximately as follows:
One-Level overcall: 6-18 points.
Two-Level overcall: 8-18 points.
In addition do not overlook the importance of:
(a) Vulnerability. Be keener to overcall when non-vulnerable, because (doubled) undertricks are cheaper.
(b) Shape. Hands with singletons and/or side four-card suits are much more powerful than the sterile 5332.
Exercise: Which of these are worth a vulnerable 1 ♠ overcall over a 1 ♦ opener?
Hand a) | Hand b) | Hand c) | Hand d) |
♠ K9865 ♥ QJ ♦ J842 ♣ Q10 |
♠ KQJ102 ♥ 87 ♦ Q1096 ♣ 97 |
♠ A9874 ♥ J7 ♦ Q52 ♣ J84 |
♠ AJ1093 ♥ J ♦ Q105 ♣ J1074 |
No | Yes | No | Yes |
Remember: think TRICKS not POINTS when deciding whether to overcall. The second hand above rates to take at least four tricks in a spade contract even if facing nothing; the first and third could end up with just one.
If South had kept quiet on our featured deal with the fourth hand above, West would have dredged up a 1 ♥ response and East-West would sail into the making 4 ♥ (losing just two spades and the ace of clubs). South’s 1 ♠ overcall prevented the 1 ♥ bid, and East-West’s heart fit was lost.
East Deals Both Vul |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
West | North | East | South |
1 ♦ | 1 ♠1 | ||
Pass2 | 3 ♠3 | Pass | Pass |
Pass |
|
3 ♠ by South |
Lead: ♦ J |
Against 3 ♠, West led the jack of diamonds (top of two). East won the king and South dropped a deceptive queen. Falling for the bait, East switched to a trump (West thus never scoring his diamond ruff). Declarer drew trumps, then ran the jack of clubs to East’s king. East cashed the ace of hearts and led a second heart, but declarer ruffed and ran the ten of clubs. A third club to dummy’s ace felled West’s queen, and a diamond was later conceded to East’s ace. Nine tricks made.