Answer #48
Three possible hands are given for South, but only one is consistent with their bidding. Which one? What would the others hands have bid differently? Both non-vulnerable.
North |
|
East |
|
South |
|
West |
4 ♥ |
|
5 ♦ |
|
1 ♥
6 ♥
|
|
2 ♦ |
Hand a) |
♠ Q J 3
♥ K Q J 5 4 3 2
♦ 4 3
♣ A |
|
Hand b) |
♠ K Q 10
♥ A Q 10 5 3 2
♦ 6 4 3 2
♣ - - |
|
Hand c) |
♠ A 9 3 2
♥ A J 9 8 2
♦ Q
♣ A Q 2 |
Answer:
(b) is correct.
-
Naturally there’s an element of guesswork here, but Hand (b) has become massive, for surely partner must have a void diamond. Even 7♥ could be on facing ♠A and ♥K, but that would be too big a gamble.
-
Hand (a) is far better suited to play than defence with those hearts that will be worth nothing defending 5♦. But you’d expect to lose perhaps one spade and one diamond, so 5♥ is sufficient.
-
Hand (c) looks powerful defensively and as it’s normally right to defend at the five-level, I’d double and take what looks like +300 / +500 rather than potentially struggle to make 5♥.